Monday, June 9, 2014

Review of Fifty Degrees Below by Kim Stanley Robinson

Forty Signs of Rain identifying the themes and mode for Kim Stanley Robinson’s Science in the Capital series, Fifty Degrees Below (2006), as is expected in the middle novel of a trilogy, further unpacks the ideas under discussion while escalating story to new heights of excitement.  Salting what was a rather tasteless opening, the second novel improves upon the first while launching the story into the third and conclusory volume, Sixty Days and Counting.

Working with the same cast of characters, Fifty Degrees Below opens with Frank Vanderwal having to leave the apartent where he was staying and search for a new home.  The flood now receded, its effects remain.  Housing prices and rent through the roof given the lack of supply and huge demand, Frank opts for creative domesticity.  Dividing time between his van, a homemade treehouse in a local park, and the showers at work, he soon settles into a routine that allows him to focus on what Diane, his boss at the NSF, has laid for him to do: think of plausible ideas that can be implemented to combat climate change.  With the jetstream sweeping ever southward, drawing the cold with it, Frank is under pressure.  Charlie Quibler, still advisor to Senator Phil Chase, is faced with a new task: a presidential campaign.  Caring for little Joe during the day while Anna works, Charlie has to back a man who, does not implement every environmental mitigation plan, but is at least a sight better than the man currently in office.  Let the campaigning begin.

Where pacing may have been an issue for readers uninterested in the subjects under discussion in Forty Signs of Rain, Robinson shifts the balance in Fifty Degrees Below.  Frank’s story mainly in the spotlight, his time in the park tracking animals that escaped from the Washington DC Zoo during the flood, playing ultimate frisbee with the neo-hippies that live on the margins of civilization, relating to the homeless who also call the park home, trying to find the mysterious woman he met in the elevator, and getting back to the basics of life in his treehouse are all related in a fashoin that makes the pages turn—especially after learning he and several others at the NSF are targets for observation by the department of Homeland Security.  Robinson playing out Frank’s line nicely, the story escalates over the last fifty pages to a subtle, but exciting crescendo.

Given Frank is the main focus, the reader is privy to his thoughts, habits, and behavior.  Presented in altruistic fashion (a la an Arthur C. Clarke hero), Frank’s scientific knowledge and inquiries range the spectrum from climatology to paleontology, and never is his thirst quenched.  When cold weather sets in, he’s found helping all he can, going to homeless shelters, building plastic lean-tos for his down-on-their-luck friends in the park, and helping to re-capture lost zoo animals—all the while helping to come up with a solution that will re-balance the catastrophic changes that have come about environmentally.  A sci-fi Mary Sue figure for it, it may be possible the reader will be turned off by his altruistic personality.  But to do so would be to miss Robinson’s point.

The Khambali Tibetan storyline given more detail in Fifty Degrees Below, Frank’s presentation as Mister Perfect is not intended to be realistic.  A representation, Frank is intended to be inspirational, to provide a goal for others to strive for.  He’s concerned about his health so he stays fit.   He is concerned about the state of the environment, so he does his part to combat negative impact.  He is concerned about society, so he does what he can pitch in.  And lastly, life is interesting to him, so he digs into the facts available.  And so while Robinson obviously had a lot of fun imagining Frank’s day-to-day, it’s easy to see he serves as an example of a socially responsible world citizen.  As sugar sweet as he may be, the world would be a better place were more people to engage with life and society in the same fashion.

But Frank’s character is only bread.  The meat and cheese (sorry for the poor metaphor) are the politics which have allowed the environmental situation to go unchecked.  A cynical tone to the chapter interludes, Robinson makes the reader aware his stance on the state of American politicians as of 2006 is not soft.  He writes “They want a silver bullet. Some kind of technical fix that will make all the problems go away without any suffering on Wall Street.” (107) and “…there is a ten-trillion-a-year economy that also wants more consumption.  It’s like we’re working within the body of a cancerous tumor.  It’s hopeless, really.  We will simply charge over the cliff like lemmings.” (113).  At the same time, Robinson does not blame a lack of knowledge for the environmental issues.  “Clearly ignorance of the situation has not been the problem.  The problem is acting on what we know.  Maybe people will be ready for that now.  Better late than never.” (69).  This ideology, coupled with Frank’s character, serve up the socio-enviro-political agenda for the book, and the series.

In the end, Fifty Degrees Below continues to take the Science in the Capital series in two distinct directions: one highly politicized and the other mainstream plotting.  Robinson’s neo-socialist views on politics, economy, spiritual philosophy, environmental policy, and society pouring out in the narrative, readers with conservative political ideologies will balk at most of what he has to say. A tangible sense of altruism present in Frank, the main character’s storyline, may further annoy.  That Robinson, however, is attempting to offer real world solutions to some of the real world problems we are currently facing overshadows the plastic characterization.  Rather than just complaining or making snarky comments from the sidelines, he wades in hip-deep with thought out ideas rooted in science and society.  The window dressing to discussion on arguably the most important issues facing humanity in the world today, well, that would be the pulp plotting.

And what’s next in Sixty Days and Counting?   “First the great flood, now the great freeze, with widespread fires as well—what’s next? ‘There’s an excellent chance of drought next summer.’” (363)

1 comment:

  1. Just read Green Earth, which edits this trilogy down into a single big novel. I'd read the trilogy over a decade ago, and my opinion then echoed yours. But Green Earth, in contrast, reads to me like a masterpiece; it felt like a juicy Great American Novel. I'd now rank it up there with Aurora as his best. Worth checking out for fans of Stan let down by the original Science in the Capital trilogy.