Guy Gavriel Kay has become, like many aging writers, a one note tune. He has been churning out the same cut/paste novels for the past decade. This is fortunate and unfortunate. As the market has made clear, there is a large swathe of readers who want dependable product. But there are also readers who look to storytelling to be an art, an idea that inherently requires innovation, evolution, and experimentation. Does Kay's latest, Written on the Dark (2025), buck his own trend?
Written on the Dark is the fictional biography of one Thierry Villar, a tavern poet. More episodic than overarching, the book picks and chooses the events of the poet's life relevant to how it shapes his fate. Skipping Villar's childhood, the book opens in his youth in the alleys and waterholes of the city of Orange (a clear medieval French analog). Villar is a talent recognized by the city's aristocracy, but he reserves his most subtle barbs for critiquing their feudal rule. That is, until broader events in the city drag him into court politics.