Thursday, October 22, 2026

Review of The Iron Code: Stories in Honour of David Gemmell edited by Ian Whates

I am no expert on David Gemmell's oeuvre. Aside from the Macedon series, what I've read goes too far into ultra-nerd D&D land—the deep sub-sub-sub reddits debating lore minutiae. Seeing Ian Whates' anthology The Iron Code: Stories in Honour of David Gemmell (2026), however, my interest was piqued. What would such ideas be like in short form, a form which does not allow for such excavation?

The Iron Code kicks off with the tasty, twisting tale of two veterans trading war stories over a drink and a hearth, “The Other” by Dan Abnett. It needed another edit to tighten up some details, but the delicately appropriate ending makes it a nesting doll worth unpacking. “Crows and Ashes” by Kari Sperring is more vignette than story—and is as gothic in mood as can be. A prioress living at the base of a mountain sees the ravages of war wash past the nunnery in the spring melt. It spurs her to action, necessitating a hike. Stylistically the story is tumultuous, but when it's on, it's dead on.

The Iron Code possesses a story from Capt. Vanilla himself, “Candles” by Adrian Tchaikovsky. It tells of an entombed knight who is resurrected by a grave robber (necromunda in hand, natch). The story emulates what made Gemmell cheesy—simple comedy, on the nose sword-and-sorcery, and diffuse purpose. Likewise, I felt I was missing something, like there was a prerequisite to the story I was not privy to, and therefore couldn't understand/enjoy as much as was possible. “Chung Kwai's Sister” by Eliza Chan has the tone of a legend. One woman goes into the pits of hell to free her hideously ugly twin brother. A cauldron frothing with Chinese mythology, it's a mini-mini-Journey to the West. “Shadow of the Ice Cross” by RJ Barker uses excellent authorial voice to tell of a tribal warrior hardened to ignore fear, until he can't. It has a nice lilt and flow, leading to a dark ending.

The collapse of a Medieval society as witnessed by an elderly chemist, “The Apothecary” by Stephen Deas is a sharp, effectively written tale that is likely as much commentary on the state of politics in the West today (not necessary for enjoyment) as it is story. “The Necessary Sword by M. R. Carey” is about a golem in an army of golems; or, how a clay man came to get its one and only tattoo. Carey captures a lot with a little. “The Calaker” by Stan Nicholls is Gemmell imitation borne of respect. Bone simple prose tells of two sword & sorcery brothers who become entangled in one town's politics involving a powerful numinous object. (Is there any other type?)

A peculiar tale of motherhood, “The Swordsman's Daughter” by Sunyi Dean is a gender-swapped warrior(ess) who is forced to make hard decisions when her hard life puts her in a hard spot. “The Witchfinder” by Joanne Harris is a Brothers Grimm-esque fairy tale of wimpy proportion. A witchfinder meets his match because... she's a witch. Last minute homework.

A classic story that is perhaps too classic, “The Code” by Mark Lawrence tells of Viking warriors, one old and one young, butting heads in a tavern one evening. They fight. That's it. Nothing special. “Fae-Blighted” by Anna Stephens is an engaging story about a demon hunter who arrives at an inn one evening, looking for her lost mate. The folk there want to hear a story, and does she give them one. In the telling, the hunter peels back layers of of the setting's reality, making for a clever ending. In “The Wolf in Winter” by Jonathan Green, a campfire surrounded by brigands drifts into story. But before morning, the only thing alive is the fire. The legends may have been true. Disposable fiction, but in a happy meal sort of way, toy included.

Take a skeleton, chant about the skeleton—milky white white bones, the whitest of milk, bones, white white, bones. Then try to imagine the human. You can't. I appreciate that “A Mighty Battle Between Mighty Armies” by Anna Smith Spark is trying something different prosaically. But in order to make generic fantasy intriguing, you need character and plot details. “Mighty” is just the skeleton. Can't have a person without meat and sinew, skin and hair.

“The Binding: A Banished Lands Tale” by John Gwynne tells of a clan of giants returning home after months fighting abroad for honor and treasure. But just as they are settling into the laurels of their victories, surprise! Drama happens. It's a sloppily written story that seems to require broader knowledge of the setting to properly appreciate. Not sure what to say about “A Trim Reckoning” by J. L. Worrad. A bit of bawdy fun, two prostitutes are escorted drunkenly home and get into a spot of trouble in a back alley. Story? Interlude? Comic relief? Right back after these messages? Not sure what to say...

A swordswoman's bloody past comes back to haunt her when a sorcerer wants revenge in “The Hiring Fayre” by Ian Whates—a classically styled story if there were. “Know When to Walk Away” by Gavin Smith is an outlier in the anthology for being urban fantasy. A boy reading pulp magazines under the blankets lets his imagination go a little too far. Or not? Bookending the anthology is “One More Day” by James Barclay. A watchtower lookout has his evening's peace disturbed by a sorcerer with subtle powers. He witnesses a war without swords, bringing his own life and purpose into question.

In the end, The Iron Code is a solid collection of stories. Twenty-one total, 99% of which is the dark/heroic fantasy variety. Whates gets a decent amount of variety from the writers solicited. In other words, don't be put off by the theme if Gemmell isnt your bag. Could easily have been epic fantasy / swords-and-sorcery / grimdark anthology from lesser known but quality writers. For such fans, it comes recommended. The quality of individual stories will vary depending on the reader, but one thing that can be objectively said is that the handful of stories set in previously established settings and lore are more difficult to connect with.


The following are the twenty-one stories anthologized in The Iron Code:

The Other by Dan Abnett
Crows and Ashes by Kari Sperring
Candles by Adrian Tchaikovsky
Chung Kwai's Sister by Eliza Chan
Shadow of the Ice Cross by RJ Barker
The Apothecary by Stephen Deas
The Necessary Sword by M. R. Carey
The Calaker by Stan Nicholls
The Swordsman's Daughter by Sunyi Dean
The Witchfinder by Joanne Harris
Lessons in Life and Death by Juliet E. McKenna
The Code by Mark Lawrence
Fae-Blighted by Anna Stephens
The Wolf in Winter by Jonathan Green
Bloodhorn by Anne Nichols
A Mighty Battle Between Mighty Armies by Anna Smith Spark
The Binding: A Banished Lands Tale by John Gwynne
A Trim Reckoning by J. L. Worrad
The Hiring Fayre by Ian Whates
Know When to Walk Away by Gavin Smith
One More Day by James Barclay

No comments:

Post a Comment