Sunday, November 22, 2026

Review of Greybeard by Brian Aldiss

It's not unexpected that Brian Aldiss' more mainstream novels are those which have stuck around the longest in cultural memory. Non-Stop, Hothouse, the Helliconia trilogy—these are the novels most sf readers these days would likely have heard of, if at all. But they do not represent the best of Aldiss' oeuvre—popular yes, but not his most rigorous or defining works. It was thus with some hesitation I went into Greybeard (1964)—another one of his more recognized works.

Like Leigh Brackett's The Long Tomorrow, John Christopher's The Children of Grass, John Crowley's Engine Summer, Emily St. John Mandel's Station Eleven, and other such works, Greybeard is a post-apocalypse of bucolic proportion. The Accident happened decades ago, disrupting Van Allen radiation belts, rendering men and women infertile. Algy Timberlane (aka Greybeard) and his wife Martha, now in their fifties, were the last generation. At the start of the novel, the pair squeeze out an existence in a town of one hundred people, trying to avoid the dangers of larger human populations and the fight for resources they know exist there. But the couple are forced out of their home due to a burgeoning stoat population, and decide to take a boat downriver to see if a better life is possible by the sea. It may just be so.

On this downriver journey, Greybeard features flashbacks to the time just after The Accident when the anthill of humanity was well and truly kicked and society as trying to find a new way. Algy and Martha head to a place they know is militarily controlled but desire the stability and control of such a life. After being disavowed of the notion, Algy finds himself part of a historical conservation team, which leads to the thematic substance of the novel. What is worth preserving? Is it worth preserving? Is humanity capable of rectifying its misdeeds for future generations? Does nature even care?

Aldiss' prose is clean and flowing. It's easy to get into the groove and go with it. But the story still comes across flat, somehow. Algy and his wife's journey downriver is more episodic than developing, a feeling which the flashbacks only enhance. They come across the absurdities one would expect to find (especially readers of Russel Hoban's Ridley Walker) and arrive at rather predictable circumstances. I rarely criticize Aldiss, but this is a case where I think the film Children of Men (roughly based on the P.D. James novel) does it better. Featuring a very similar premise, it possesses the edge that Greybeard lacks, however—the dogged knowledge that the human stakes are real.

In the end, I see why Greybeard is a beloved novel. Like George Stewart's Earth Abides, it possesses an interesting concept and asks some big questions. But it lacks certain details of setting and character to give the narrative the gravitas it needed. As noted, the film Children of Men imposes upon the viewer the meaning of humanity being unable to conceive. They feel the tension, unlike Greybeard which floats, almost drifting into comedy at times. Crowley's Engine Summer and Hoban's Ridley Walker pull that tone off with success; Greybeard, not enough. I rarely say this, but Aldiss' book needed 100-200 more pages for proper grounding and to give the big questions the soil they needed to fully blossom. (Apologies for the shitty metaphors.)

No comments:

Post a Comment